Topics
Series
Media type
Topics
Featured topics
Arts & Media
Economics
Environment
Governance & Politics
Health
Human rights
Peace & Conflict
Social movements
Technology
Series
Featured series
Doha Debates
Doha Debates Podcast
The Negotiators
Town Halls
Media type
All media types
Podcasts
Videos
Articles
Topics
Featured topics
Arts & Media
Economics
Environment
Governance & Politics
Health
Human rights
Peace & Conflict
Social movements
Technology
Series
Featured series
Doha Debates
Doha Debates Podcast
The Negotiators
Town Halls
Media types
Podcasts
Videos
Articles
April 07, 2026

Fate vs. free will: Do we make our own choices?

S2 E12 122 MINS

Are we in control of our choices, or is free will an illusion? 

 

Groundbreaking neuroscience and behavioral psychology suggest that our decisions might be dictated by internal processes we don’t consciously control. So how much free will do we actually have? And what does that mean for human systems built on the idea that we’re in charge of our own behavior?

From Islamic perspectives to neuroscientific theories, this episode examines how differing conceptions of free will influence the way we look at morality, responsibility and justice. Are we truly able to shape our own lives, or are we following a script we can’t rewrite? And if we don’t have genuine free will, does that mean we should rethink punishment, praise and everything in between?





Participants

FX 03113 104 104

Shadi Hamid

Columnist, the Washington Post
Co-host, Wisdom of Crowds podcast

FX 03072 e1775574828186 104 104

Heather Berlin

Associate professor of psychiatry and neuroscience, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai

FX 03125 e1775572848779 104 104

Peter Tse

Cognitive neuroscientist, professor and chair of the Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Dartmouth College

Gregg Caruso Headshot e1772643119174 104 104

Gregg Caruso

mal 104 104

Malika Bilal

More on this topic

DD TOWN HALL FREE WILL THUMB CLEAN e1770743860921 570 320
Faith & Ethics

Doha Debates Town Hall: Do we really have free will?

Town Halls
89 MINS
231012 DDP S1EP12 CLEAN lmb resized for web 570 320
Faith & Ethics

WATCH: Joyce Harper and Sarah Chan debate the ethics of gene editing

Doha Debates Podcast
S1E1236 MINS
231012 DDP S1EP12 CLEAN lmb resized for web 570 320
icon
Faith & Ethics

Ethics of editing: Is genetic engineering worth the risk?

Doha Debates Podcast
S1E1236 MINS
WebThumb 4 570 320
Faith & Ethics

WATCH: Dr. Katherine Roe and Dr. Juan Carlos G. Marvizón debate whether we should ban animal experiments

Doha Debates Podcast
S1E741 MINS
WebThumb 4 570 320
icon
Faith & Ethics

Testing our ethics: Should we ban animal experiments?

Doha Debates Podcast
S1E738 MINS
DD Townhall Video Thumbnail 960 540 2 570 320
Health

Should we engineer a world without disability? (Arabic)

Town Halls
61 MINS
THWish2022Clean 570 320
Health

Should we engineer a world without disability? (English)

Town Halls
62 MINS
221104 TWSP S1 EP2CLEAN 570 320
Faith & Ethics

Ethical AI: Are we getting it right? (Blake Lemoine and Dex Hunter-Torricke)

Doha Debates Podcast
43 MINS
Ibtihaj Thumbnail blank 570 320
Arts & Media

The Long Game: A conversation with Ibtihaj Muhammad

The Long Game
66 MINS
Mohamed Salah Long Game episode 3 2 site 570 320
icon
Faith & Ethics

Mohamed Salah changed attitudes. Other athletes can too.

The Long Game
S1E822 MINS